Independence and APES 110

An audit is only worth something if the auditor stands apart from the people who prepare the fund's accounts. Here is what the rules ask, in plain words, and how we meet them.

What the rules ask

Independent in fact and in appearance

APES 110, the Code of Ethics for Professional Accountants (including Independence Standards), asks every auditor to be independent in mind and in appearance. For SMSF audits, the ATO and ASIC expect an auditor not to audit a fund where they, or their firm, prepared the accounts or gave the advice, unless the threats to independence are dealt with properly.

Where independence is most often at risk

Arrangements to look at closely

Audits inside the same firmWhere the firm that prepares the accounts, or a related firm, also audits them (the self-review threat).
Network firmsWhere the auditor and the preparer share owners, names or systems.
Reciprocal auditsTwo firms auditing each other's clients.
Long relationshipsThe same auditor on the same fund for many years (the familiarity threat).
FeesWhere the audit fee depends on other work, or one client is a large share of the auditor's income.

Each of these can sometimes be managed with safeguards; some can't. The ATO has warned about independence in in-house and network audit arrangements.

How we stay independent

We only audit

  • SMSF Audits Pty Ltd only audits. We don't prepare accounts or give advice on the funds we audit.
  • Dhan Accountants is a separate company that prepares SMSF accounts. We never audit a fund whose accounts Dhan prepared.
  • We have no reciprocal arrangements with any firm.
  • Our fees don't depend on the outcome of an audit.

Your firm's own position

Checking your firm's arrangements

If your firm prepares SMSF accounts and also audits them, or uses a related or reciprocal auditor, APES 110 asks you to look at the threats and the safeguards. Our independence check, which walks through the main questions, is being updated.

General information only, not advice for your firm's situation.

Want an auditor who stands apart? Send us a fund.

Ask for an engagement letter and access to our client portal. We reply within one working day.